Legislative storm takes aim on Florida amid hurricane season
June 1 marks the start of hurricane season – a date Floridians know well.
But as meteorologists keep a watchful eye on the Atlantic and Gulf Coasts this summer, my attention will be focused on Washington where a powerful storm of legislation is brewing that would make it more difficult to obtain and afford the insurance we need to stay protected against natural disasters.
Almost 25 years ago, Hurricane Andrew changed the face of the insurance marketplace in a dramatic way. Up until that point, neither consumers nor insurance companies understood the catastrophic risk exposure to our state. Insurance companies failed and many large insurance companies retreated or significantly reduced its exposure in Florida. A new Florida domestic homeowners’ market and our own Florida Hurricane Catastrophe Fund were born in the wake of Hurricane Andrew. While time does have a way of erasing our memories, Florida endured the four storms of the 2004 season and these new companies and the CAT Fund came through battered but withstanding the unrecognized risk of having a year with multiple catastrophic events. Part of the reason that this market survived and continues to prosper has been because of private international reinsurance. In fact, 91 percent of private insurance for Florida homeowner insurers is from international reinsurers. Now, two proposals that may be included in upcoming corporate tax reform plans seek to shrink Florida’s insurance and reinsurance market, leaving our state’s consumers with higher costs for the same insurance coverage.
More:Guest view: School choice will lift up black community
One proposal, crafted by US Rep. Richard Neal (D-MA) and introduced in previous Congresses and in past administration budget messages, would deny tax deductions unfairly to domestic insurers for certain reinsurance premiums paid to foreign-based affiliates. The other proposal – the border-adjusted tax featured in the House Ways and Means Committee Chairman Kevin Brady’s (R-TX) Blueprint for Tax Reform – if applied to international reinsurance would dramatically reduce the supply and increase the price of reinsurance upon which Florida’s economy depends.
Florida TaxWatch, an independent nonprofit taxpayer research institute, recently released a study that found that a 20 percent border-adjusted tax, if applied to international reinsurance, could directly cost policyholders between $430 and $910 more per year. The tax would increase the cost of commercial and residential property insurance in Florida by $1.4 - $2.6 billion annually. The effects of this extra burden would be immediate and severe. It would reduce economic activity by $2.8 - $5.0 billion, worker earnings by $1.4 - $2.6 billion and employment by approximately 42,800 – 77,400 jobs.
In the face of the existing crisis around the Assignment of Benefits issue which will also operate to push insurance premiums up, Floridians cannot afford a proposed tax increase that more than likely make insurance too expensive for existing homeowners and business owners, will make home ownership unaffordable in our recovering housing market and push new businesses from opening and existing businesses from expanding.
More:Guest view: Time to invest in community’s future
Global insurers and reinsurers play a significant role by diversifying catastrophic risk globally leading to lower prices and more coverage that benefits the state and national economy. Foreign insurers and reinsurers have a long history supporting our state the wake of hurricanes. Simply put, our current Florida insurance marketplace cannot exist without it. The proposed tax increase will go to Florida’s bottom line, increasing rates and undermining our insurance marketplace. Our system is not perfect but Floridians cannot afford to lose the stability we have gained through managing our risk with this very important tool…..international reinsurance.
The 2016 Atlantic hurricane season was the first above average season since 2012. As we prepare for this year’s wave of storms, I urge Florida’s congressional delegation, including Senators Bill Nelson and Marco Rubio, to oppose misguided and discriminatory proposals that leave our state vulnerable to higher insurance prices.
Robin Westcott was formerly the Director of Insurer Solvency & Acting Deputy Insurance Commissioner, P&C with the Florida Office of Insurance Regulation and served under CFO Jeff Atwater as Florida’s Insurance Consumer Advocate.